Ranking Possible Soulsborne Sequels from Worst to Best

5. Dark Souls 4
4. Demon’s Souls 2
3. Elden Ring 2
2. Bloodborne 2
1. Sekiro 2

FromSoftware has built a legacy of legendary games, but what comes next for the studio? Many are looking for a sequel to one of their classics. For this article, I’m ranking the possible sequels we could see—from worst to best.

“Worst”, in this case, would mean a game I would be disappointed if I heard that FromSoftware was working on it actively.

5. Dark Souls 4

There’s a part of me that would happily take more Dark Souls forever. I’ve never been truly disappointed by a new FromSoft game—each one delivers new challenges and reignites my love for gaming. And it does so in a way that no other series can.

But here’s the problem: Dark Souls has already told its story. Between the three main games and six DLCs, it’s the most complete package FromSoft has ever made. Each entry even has its own identity:

• Dark Souls 1 focused on world-building and exploration.
• Dark Souls 2 emphasized build variety, multiplayer, and deliberate combat.
• Dark Souls 3 went all-in on fast, epic, boss-driven intensity.

By the third game, the series was already repeating elements from earlier titles. It feels like every corner of that universe has been explored. At least for now.

Don’t get me wrong—if Miyazaki announced a Dark Souls 4, I’d still buy it day one. But every project he takes on consumes years of his creative energy. When people once complained about him starting a new IP instead of making a sequel, that “new IP” turned out to be Elden Ring. Sometimes stepping away is how we get something even bigger.

So as much as I’d enjoy another Dark Souls, I think it’s time to let that trilogy remain complete. At least for another decade or so.

4. Demon’s Souls 2

There was a time when Demon’s Souls 2 would have made a lot of sense. In truth, what it really needed was a DLC back in the day—it’s one of the only FromSoft titles without one, and it feels unfinished because of that.

Still, Demon’s Souls has its own unique feel compared to later games. With linear levels, a single checkpoint, and more “video game-y” design choices, it would be fascinating to see a modern reimagining of that formula. The Bluepoint remake on PS5 also breathed fresh life into the franchise, making it feel more relevant than ever.

That said, if FromSoft chose this as their next big project, I’d feel disappointed. Dark Souls is already its spiritual successor, and gaming has moved on from many of the clunkier mechanics Demon’s Souls relied on. Fans might say they want those stripped-back systems, but most players don’t actually enjoy losing some quality of life elements that we’ve unlocked. Stakes of Marika and fast travel are additions that are likely here to stay.

So while I’d be curious to see a Demon’s Souls 2, it might end up feeling like an attempt to recapture a nostalgic past rather than pushing forward.

3. Elden Ring 2

Elden Ring is absolutely massive. Its huge base game and gigantic DLC together make it the biggest FromSoft experience ever. In a way, it already feels like a complete package that doesn’t need a sequel.

But here’s the thing—the potential is limitless. The Lands Between are so rich in lore and worldbuilding that FromSoft could easily make multiple sequels without running out of material.

The downside is timing. Elden Ring has dominated gaming culture for years, and we’ve been living in its shadow ever since launch. It feels too soon to go back, especially with spin-offs like Nightreign already appearing.

That said, the beauty of Elden Ring is how flexible it is. FromSoft could introduce bold new mechanics in a sequel without breaking its identity. Flying mounts? Sure. Expanded traversal? Why not. The foundation is whacky enough to handle wild ideas in a way Dark Souls never could.

So yes, Elden Ring 2 would be fun—but it needs to wait a while.

2. Bloodborne 2

You probably expected this to be number one. And believe me, as a shameless Bloodborne fanboy, this was a tough call.

The reason it doesn’t take the top spot is that Bloodborne already feels like a complete story. The push for a sequel is mostly because we adore the first game, not necessarily because it demands continuation.

That said, there’s plenty of room for evolution. Bloodborne’s mechanics aren’t as rigid as Dark Souls, and I can easily imagine improvements such as:

• A refined parry system inspired by Sekiro.
• Streamlined healing to replace blood vial farming.
• More hunter-style bosses rather than puzzle-oriented ones.

And with fans having mastered the original, a sequel could start at a higher difficulty baseline, matching the level of challenge found in the DLC.

So yes, Bloodborne 2 would be a dream come true—but there’s one other sequel I think deserves to come first.

1. Sekiro 2

This is my pick for the best souls-like sequel.

Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice has the most refined combat in the entire FromSoft library, but it’s painfully short. On repeat runs, I can clear every boss in just 4–5 hours. For such a brilliant combat system, there just isn’t enough content.

And unlike the others, Sekiro never got a DLC. That still stings. The framework for an expansion was all there, but it never came. At this point, I’d still happily take one—but since that ship has sailed, the next best thing would be a full sequel.

Imagine another journey through Japan, with new biomes, new bosses, and expanded combat mechanics. With the foundation already perfected, FromSoft could push Sekiro 2 to new heights.

For me, that’s the sequel I’d want most.

Bonus: A Brand-New IP

But the reality is, the thing that I want the most is a brand new IP. The most likely outcome is that FromSoft skips sequels altogether and brings us with something new. As Elden Ring proved, letting Miyazaki and his team break free from expectations can create something even more beloved than what came before.

Whether it’s Sekiro 2, Bloodborne 2, or a brand-new universe, one thing’s for sure: whatever FromSoft does next, we’ll all be lining up to play it.